Assess/Evaluate

Im Englischen bedeutet assess/evaluate $\rightarrow$ bewerten, beurteilen, oder einschätzen
Diese Art von Aufgabenstellung liegt im Anforderungsniveau III.
Es beinhaltet eine umfassende Untersuchung und Berücksichtigung verschiedener Aspekte eines Textes, Films, Zitates oder auch einer Karikatur.

Im Abi könnte die Aufgabenstellung beispielsweise so lauten:
Assess to what extent Walt and Father Janovich in Gran Torino are each other's mentors.

Introduction
In der Einleitung sollten die Schlüsselaspekte des zu bewertenden Texts, Zitats, Films oder auch der Karikatur genannt werden, darunter Titel, Autor sowie Veröffentlichungsdatum und -ort.
Anschließend folgt eine knappe Erläuterung der Aufgabe im Zusammenhang mit dem jeweiligen Beispiel.

In the movie "Gran Torino," by Clint Eastwood Walt Kowalski and Father Janovich play significant roles in each other's lives, but their relationship is more complex than a traditional mentor-mentee dynamic. While they influence and impact each other in various ways, it would be more accurate to describe their relationship as a mutual learning experience rather than a traditional mentorship.

Main Body
Oft müssen bei einer assess/evaluate-Aufgabe, zwei Sachverhalte zueinander bewertet werden.
In diesem Beispiel muss bewertet werden, in welchem Ausmaß die zwei Charaktere Walt und Father Janovich als Mentoren füreinander fungierten.
Beginne damit das Verhalten als Mentor beider Personen unabhängig voneindander zu beschreiben.

Walt as mentor figure:

Father Janovich is a young and idealistic Catholic priest who wants to connect with Walt and his community
he initially seeks to serve as a spiritual guide for Walt, offering him advice and trying to understand him better
however, Father Janovich's attempts are often met with resistance, rejection and sarcasm from Walt
...

Father Janovich as mentor figure:

Father Janovich is a young and idealistic Catholic priest who wants to connect with Walt and his community
he initially seeks to serve as a spiritual guide for Walt, offering him advice and trying to understand him better
however, Father Janovich's attempts are often met with resistance, rejection and sarcasm from Walt
as the story progresses, Father Janovich learns valuable lessons from Walt's experiences and actions
...

Danach wird beurteilt, inwiefern beide Charaktere jeweils die Rolle des Mentors für den anderen erfüllen.

Mutual learning experience:

While Walt acts as a mentor to Tao, his relationship with Father Janovich can be described more as a mutual learning experience
as Father Janovich tries to understand and connect with Walt, he begins to recognize the depth of Walt's character and the reasons behind his prejudices
Father Janovich learns to appreciate the complexities of human nature, challenges his own preconceptions, and gains a more nuanced perspective on life
simultaneously, Walt also learns from Father Janovich's unwavering faith, humility, and compassion
through his interactions with Father Janovich, Walt starts questioning his own beliefs and realizes the importance of forgiveness and redemption
Father Janovich's presence serves as a catalyst for Walt's personal growth and transformation
...

Conclusion
Anschließend werden in einem Fazit die Ergebnisse deiner Bewertung zusammengefasst.

In conclusion, while Walt Kowalski and Father Janovich impact each other's lives and serve as significant influences, their relationship in "Gran Torino" can be better characterized as a mutual learning experience rather than a traditional mentorship.
Walt acts as a mentor figure to Thao, while Father Janovich plays a role in challenging Walt's beliefs and facilitating his personal growth.