Thema 11: Truth and Lies
Prüfling A
According to surveys, the average person tells lies several times a day. Comment on the cartoon.
https://www.facebook.com/BusinessToday/photos/cartoon-customer-trust-has-gone-through-the-roof-ever-since-we-started-lying-abo/10161775467990300
[accessed: 22 March 2022]
[accessed: 22 March 2022]
Agree on steps everyone could take to foster truthfulness.
Prüfling B
According to surveys, the average person tells lies several times a day. Comment on the cartoon.
https://twitter.com/larsgrotewold/status/1017333699552083969
[accessed: 22 March 2022]
[accessed: 22 March 2022]
Agree on steps everyone could take to foster truthfulness.
Prüfling C
According to surveys, the average person tells lies several times a day. Comment on the cartoon.
https://brightside.me/inspiration-psychology/science-explains-how-little-white-lies-can-harm-our-kids-800669/ [accessed: 22 March 2022]
Agree on steps everyone could take to foster truthfulness.
Weiter lernen mit SchulLV Plus!
monatlich kündbarSchulLV Plus-Vorteile im ÜberblickDu hast bereits einen Account?
Note:
Please note that these solutions are only suggestions. There are various possibilities for argumentation.
Please note that these solutions are only suggestions. There are various possibilities for argumentation.
- Let's start with...
- On the one hand / on the other hand
- It must be considered
- In my opinion / I think, personally, ...
- I agree / I disagree
Possible introductions to the topic and the argumentation
Prüfungsteilnehmer A
- the cartoon shows a business scenario in which the presenter states that "customer trust has gone through the roof ever since [they] started lying about [their] product" with a statistic in the background showing trust and lie correlating over time
- that customer confidence increases along with the lie could give the impression that the lie is justified
- in reality however, as soon as the lie is exposed, trust falls rapidly and is impossible to rebuild
- Customer trust is a fragile asset that should be spared, because trust can damage companies immensely
Comment on the material
lying in business
lying in business
Prüfungsteilnehmer B
- the cartoon shows a movie theater with two entrances to two different movies
- one movie is called "an inconvenient truth" and the other "a reassuring lie" a long people queue for the movie "a reassuring lie"
- the cartoon reflects our society, in which unpleasant issues are not addressed and tackled, and in which the path of least resistance is often chosen
Comment on the cartoon
a reassuring lie
a reassuring lie
Prüfungsteilnehmer C
- the cartoon depicts a father-son situation, in which the father lies to the son, telling him that they will go to the park, when instead he is trying to take him to the dentist without resistance
- this situation most likely occurs in everyday life more often than one would like to assume
- while parents are convinced to take away their children's fear, this lie can destroy children's trust in their parents
- especially at a young age, children are shaped by their parents, not only about trust, but also about when a lie is acceptable and when it is not
Comment on the cartoon
lying as parenting meassure
lying as parenting meassure
Argumente für beide Prüfungsteilnehmer
- personal relationships: Lies in personal relationships can have detrimental effects, eroding trust and leading to emotional distance.
Open and honest communication is essential for building strong connections. - professional life: While honesty is crucial in professional settings, there are instances where lies may emerge, such as diplomacy, protecting confidentiality, or avoiding unnecessary conflict. However, habitual lying can undermine professional integrity
- social interactions: In social settings, lies can sometimes be used to protect someone's feelings or maintain social harmony. However, constant deception can erode trust and authenticity.
- media and information: The spread of misinformation and fake news has become a significant concern in the digital age. Truthful information is crucial for an informed society.
roles of lies in different spheres of life
- foster truthfulness in personal relationships: Encourage an environment where people feel comfortable sharing their thoughts and feelings without fear of judgment or punishment. Show genuine interest in others' perspectives and validate their emotions, which can encourage them to be truthful. Lead by example; Be honest and transparent in your own interactions, demonstrating the value of truthfulness.
- promote truthfulness in the workplace: Encourage organizations to develop clear guidelines that prioritize honesty, integrity, and transparency. Encourage open communication, constructive feedback, and a supportive work environment where employees feel safe to express their thoughts and concerns honestly. Acknowledge and appreciate individuals who demonstrate truthfulness, creating incentives for ethical behavior.
- encourage truthfulness in social interactions: Promote a culture where people genuinely care about one another's feelings and opinions, fostering an atmosphere of trust and openness. Encourage direct and honest communication, even when discussing sensitive topics, by emphasizing mutual respect and understanding. Critically evaluate and challenge societal expectations that may encourage dishonesty, and strive for authenticity in social interactions.
- promote truthfulness in media and information: Encourage critical thinking and fact-checking before accepting or sharing information. Promote media literacy and rely on trustworthy sources of information, such as reputable news outlets and fact-checking organizations. Educate others about the dangers of misinformation and the importance of seeking and spreading accurate information.
how to foster truthfullness